ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART by Stephanie Garber

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber is an enchanting young adult fantasy romance filled with broken hearts, dangerous bargains, magical curses, mysterious princes and the irresistible temptation to believe that true love can still create a happily ever after.

Evangeline Fox has always believed in love.

Not practical love.

Not convenient love.

She believes in the kind found in fairy tales.

True love.

Destiny.

Happily ever after.

Then the person she believes she loves is about to marry someone else.

Heartbroken and desperate to stop the wedding, Evangeline turns to someone no sensible person should trust:

Jacks, the Prince of Hearts.

Jacks is one of the legendary Fates.

Beautiful.

Immortal.

Manipulative.

Dangerous.

And according to the stories, his kiss can be fatal to everyone except his one true love.

Evangeline knows making a deal with him is risky.

But a broken heart can make impossible choices feel reasonable.

Jacks agrees to help her.

His price sounds deceptively simple.

Three kisses.

They must be given whenever and wherever he chooses.

Evangeline accepts.

Soon she discovers that bargains with immortals are never as simple as they appear.

One wish leads to consequences she never expected.

One choice changes the direction of her life.

And Jacks appears to have plans for her that go far beyond the agreement she thought she understood.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber combines fairy-tale wonder with romantic tension, mystery, danger and a world where curses may be real, stories may change lives and happily ever after can have a very high price.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber – Book Overview

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber begins with heartbreak.

Evangeline believes the man she loves is going to marry someone else.

She could accept it.

She could walk away.

Instead, she searches for magic.

This decision brings her to the Prince of Hearts.

From that moment, the story becomes less about stopping one wedding and more about understanding what happens when a person asks magic to interfere with love.

Evangeline quickly learns that magic may grant exactly what you ask for without giving you what you truly wanted.

That distinction becomes one of the novel’s most important ideas.

Evangeline Fox

Evangeline is a heroine defined by hope.

Even when reality gives her reasons to become cynical, she continues believing:

Love matters.

Stories matter.

Happy endings are possible.

This optimism could easily make her naive.

Sometimes it does.

But it is also one of her greatest strengths.

She is willing to believe in possibilities that other characters have already dismissed.

Believing in Happily Ever After

Fairy tales often teach readers that true love will eventually overcome every obstacle.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber plays with that expectation.

What if the person you believe is your true love is not actually right for you?

What if getting what you want creates something worse?

What if the villain understands your heart better than the person you originally loved?

The story uses familiar fairy-tale ideas, then keeps twisting them.

Jacks, the Prince of Hearts

Jacks is one of the novel’s greatest attractions.

He is charming enough to make terrible decisions sound reasonable.

He appears helpful.

Then dangerous.

Then unexpectedly vulnerable.

Then suspicious again.

Readers are constantly forced to ask:

Can he be trusted?

The safest answer is probably no.

But that does not make him easier to resist.

A Dangerous Fate

Jacks is not an ordinary human prince.

He is one of the powerful beings known as the Fates.

Stories surrounding him are full of tragedy.

His kiss is legendary.

So is his inability to love normally.

This makes every romantic interaction with him feel dangerous.

Three Kisses

The bargain at the center of Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber initially seems simple.

Jacks helps Evangeline.

Evangeline owes him three kisses.

But there is an important problem.

Jacks chooses:

When.

Where.

And with whom.

A magical bargain therefore becomes a form of control.

Evangeline does not initially understand how much power she has handed him.

Be Careful What You Wish For

This is one of the oldest fairy-tale lessons.

Magic often follows the wording of a wish rather than the emotional intention behind it.

You ask for something.

Magic gives it.

Then you discover the cost.

Evangeline’s choices repeatedly demonstrate why desire and wisdom are not always the same thing.

Magic Has Consequences

Magic in the novel is beautiful.

But it is rarely harmless.

Curses change lives.

Bargains create obligations.

Kisses can be dangerous.

Prophecies can influence decisions.

This keeps the fairy-tale world from becoming purely whimsical.

Beauty and danger constantly exist together.

The Magnificent North

The story eventually expands into the Magnificent North, one of the most memorable settings in Stephanie Garber’s fantasy world.

It feels like somewhere shaped by:

Fairy tales.

Myths.

Old curses.

Royal families.

Strange traditions.

Magical doors.

Impossible stories.

The setting reinforces the feeling that Evangeline has entered a place where ordinary rules may no longer apply.

A World Built From Stories

Stories are powerful throughout Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber.

People believe legends.

Legends influence behavior.

Stories change depending on who tells them.

A tale that sounds romantic from one perspective may sound terrifying from another.

This creates uncertainty.

Readers must decide which stories contain truth.

The Prince of Hearts Myth

Jacks is surrounded by stories.

Some portray him as:

A monster.

A romantic tragedy.

A curse.

A prince waiting for his true love.

The truth may be more complicated than any single version.

This makes him feel like both a character and a fairy-tale figure inside his own world.

Love Versus Obsession

The novel repeatedly asks readers to consider the difference between genuine love and the desire to possess someone.

Wanting someone desperately does not automatically mean the relationship is healthy.

Love can become confused with:

Jealousy.

Control.

Fantasy.

Idealization.

Fear of loss.

Evangeline gradually has to understand her own feelings more clearly.

First Love

Evangeline begins the story believing she already knows who she loves.

That certainty drives her toward Jacks.

But first love is not necessarily final love.

People can misunderstand themselves.

Growing older sometimes means realizing that what felt like destiny was only one chapter.

Fate Versus Choice

The word Fate has literal importance in the novel.

But destiny is also a thematic question.

Are Evangeline’s experiences predetermined?

Are certain people meant to meet?

Can someone escape a curse?

Can choices rewrite the ending?

The story constantly balances the idea of destiny with personal agency.

Can You Change Your Story?

Evangeline wants a fairy-tale ending.

But stories are not fixed simply because someone expects them to follow a familiar pattern.

A heroine can make the wrong choice.

A villain can become emotionally complicated.

A prince may not be the hero.

A happily ever after may look different from what the protagonist originally imagined.

Romantic Fantasy

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber is primarily a young adult fantasy romance.

Romance is extremely important.

But the plot also includes:

Magic.

Mystery.

Royal intrigue.

Curses.

Danger.

Secrets.

Fairy-tale mythology.

Readers wanting both fantasy and romantic tension are likely to find a strong balance here.

Slow-Burn Romantic Tension

The chemistry between Evangeline and Jacks does not function like a simple instant relationship.

There is attraction.

But also suspicion.

Manipulation.

Frustration.

Curiosity.

Danger.

This creates strong slow-burn tension.

Readers understand why Evangeline should stay away.

The story also makes it very easy to understand why she cannot stop paying attention to him.

Is Jacks a Villain?

That depends on how strictly you define villain.

Jacks does selfish things.

He manipulates people.

He hides information.

His goals do not always align with Evangeline’s well-being.

But he is not written as a flat evil character.

His unpredictability is part of the appeal.

Morally Grey Characters

Jacks is a strong example of a morally grey love interest.

He can do something cruel and then something unexpectedly helpful.

Readers are rarely allowed to become completely comfortable with him.

That uncertainty gives the romance much of its tension.

Trust

Trust is one of Evangeline’s greatest challenges.

Who deserves it?

Who is using her?

Who is protecting her?

Who is hiding something?

In a world shaped by magical bargains and secret motives, appearances become unreliable.

Lies and Half-Truths

A character does not need to tell a direct lie to deceive someone.

They can simply omit the most important detail.

That happens repeatedly throughout fantasy built around bargains.

Understanding exact wording becomes extremely important.

Curses

Curses are central to the series.

A curse is especially powerful in fairy-tale fiction because it turns emotions into rules.

Love.

Jealousy.

Revenge.

Fear.

All can become magical forces.

The novel uses curses to create both romantic tension and mystery.

Deadly Kisses

Kissing normally represents intimacy.

With the Prince of Hearts, it can represent death.

That transforms one of romance fiction’s most familiar gestures into a threat.

The contrast is perfectly suited to the tone of the book:

Beautiful and dangerous at the same time.

Royalty

Princes, royal families and court politics become increasingly important as Evangeline enters the Magnificent North.

But Garber does not treat royalty as automatically heroic.

Titles can hide:

Ambition.

Manipulation.

Secrets.

Violence.

A crown tells you someone has power.

It does not tell you whether they deserve trust.

Apollo

Prince Apollo becomes important to Evangeline’s story as the plot develops.

His presence deepens the romantic and political complications surrounding her.

Rather than creating a simple love triangle, the novel uses different relationships to explore Evangeline’s expectations about love and destiny.

The Attraction of Fairy Tales

Why are fairy tales so compelling?

Because they promise that chaos has meaning.

The cursed person can be saved.

The lost princess can be found.

Love can defeat impossible obstacles.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber loves fairy tales while also questioning them.

Hope

Evangeline’s belief in hope may sometimes expose her to danger.

But becoming completely cynical would also cost something.

The novel suggests that maturity does not necessarily require abandoning hope.

It may instead require becoming wiser about where hope is placed.

Optimism Versus Naivety

Optimism says:

A good future is possible.

Naivety says:

Nothing bad will happen because I want a good future.

These are very different.

Evangeline’s growth involves learning to preserve hope without ignoring danger.

Heartbreak

The title immediately tells readers that heartbreak matters.

A broken heart can cause people to make:

Impulsive choices.

Desperate bargains.

Unwise promises.

Evangeline’s journey begins because she wants to escape emotional pain.

But avoiding pain does not necessarily lead toward love.

Grief and Loss

The story also contains other forms of loss.

Characters carry histories that affect how they understand:

Love.

Family.

Trust.

Belonging.

Loss becomes part of the emotional atmosphere rather than simply a plot device.

Choices Have Consequences

One choice can alter everything.

This is especially true in fairy tales.

Open the forbidden door.

Eat the apple.

Make the bargain.

Give the kiss.

Evangeline repeatedly encounters moments where a seemingly small action creates much larger consequences.

Mystery

The novel contains many unanswered questions.

What does Jacks truly want?

Which legends are accurate?

Which relationships are real?

Who can Evangeline trust?

These mysteries continue to develop across the series.

Twists

Stephanie Garber frequently uses revelations that cause readers to reinterpret earlier events.

A person who appeared trustworthy may seem suspicious.

A romantic moment may have another meaning.

A bargain may contain a hidden purpose.

Readers who enjoy twist-driven fantasy will find plenty to follow.

Beautiful but Dangerous Worldbuilding

The world of Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber often feels like:

Sugared fruit hiding poison.

Beautiful castles hiding curses.

Romantic legends hiding tragedy.

That contrast gives the book its distinctive identity.

Stephanie Garber’s Writing Style

Garber’s prose is highly visual and romantic.

She frequently emphasizes:

Color.

Clothing.

Architecture.

Food.

Magic.

Emotion.

The writing aims to make the world feel almost edible in its richness.

Readers who enjoy lush fantasy settings may especially appreciate this style.

Caraval Connection

Once Upon a Broken Heart takes place in the broader world connected to Stephanie Garber’s Caraval books, and Jacks previously appeared there.

However, this novel begins a new central storyline focused on Evangeline Fox.

You can start with Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber without needing to complete the Caraval trilogy first.

Readers who have read Caraval, Legendary and Finale may recognize additional world and character connections.

Is Once Upon a Broken Heart Book 1?

Yes.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber is officially Volume 1 / Book 1 of the series.

That makes it the correct starting point for Evangeline and Jacks’ main storyline.

Main Series Reading Order

The core Evangeline and Jacks trilogy should be read in this order:

1. Once Upon a Broken Heart
2. The Ballad of Never After
3. A Curse for True Love

Macmillan identifies The Ballad of Never After as Volume 2 and A Curse for True Love as the next major installment.

As of September 2026, Macmillan also lists The Mirror of Infinite Endings, an illustrated continuation in the Once Upon a Broken Heart universe, for release on September 22, 2026.

Should You Read The Ballad of Never After First?

No.

Begin with Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber.

The Ballad of Never After continues directly from the consequences of this first book and assumes readers already understand Evangeline, Jacks and the major magical relationships.

Is Once Upon a Broken Heart a Standalone?

No.

Although this volume has its own major plot developments, the central romance, mysteries and curses continue into later books.

Readers should expect a series rather than a completely self-contained ending.

Is It Young Adult?

Yes.

Macmillan classifies Once Upon a Broken Heart as Young Adult and gives its editions an age range of approximately 13–18.

However, suitability still depends on the individual reader because the book contains darker fairy-tale themes.

Is It Spicy?

The first book focuses much more on romantic tension, kissing, longing and emotional chemistry than explicit sexual content.

Readers looking for fantasy romance with strong tension but without adult-level explicit scenes may find it accessible.

Is It Dark Romance?

Not in the strict adult dark-romance sense.

It is better described as:

YA fantasy romance with dark fairy-tale elements and a morally grey love interest.

There are dangerous bargains, manipulation, curses and deadly supernatural consequences, but its overall style remains magical and fairy-tale oriented.

Is It Similar to Caraval?

Readers who enjoy Caraval may recognize Garber’s love of:

Mystery.

Magic.

Beautiful settings.

Dangerous games.

Romantic tension.

Unreliable appearances.

However, Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber has its own heroine and central storyline.

Is It Good for Fantasy Romance Beginners?

Yes.

The world contains magic and lore but does not require the reader to memorize an extremely complex political or magical system.

The emotional story remains easy to follow.

That makes it approachable for readers moving from contemporary romance into fantasy romance.

Paperback Edition Details

For the Flatiron Books trade paperback matching ISBN 9781250268402:

Title: Once Upon a Broken Heart
Author: Stephanie Garber
Series: Once Upon a Broken Heart #1
ISBN-13: 9781250268402
Publisher: Flatiron Books
Format: Trade Paperback
Pages: 432
Paperback Publication Date: March 28, 2023
Genre: Young Adult Fantasy / Romance

If your physical copy uses another ISBN, always enter the information printed on that specific edition.

Content Considerations

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber includes darker fairy-tale material involving magical manipulation, curses, blood, death, poisoning or magical danger, grief, romantic deception, coercive bargains, threats, violence and characters placed in dangerous situations.

The tone is generally romantic and fantastical rather than graphic horror, but parents purchasing for younger readers may still want to consider the supernatural danger and morally complicated relationships.

Important Themes

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber explores love, heartbreak, hope, fate, choice, fairy tales, dangerous bargains, magic, curses, trust, deception, destiny, romantic idealization, sacrifice, consequences, royal intrigue, stories, happy endings and the question of whether true love can survive manipulation.

7 Magical Reasons to Read Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber

1. Evangeline Fox is a heroine who refuses to stop believing in hope. Her romantic optimism gives the story emotional warmth even when the world around her becomes dangerous.
2. Jacks is an unforgettable morally grey love interest. Charming, manipulative, mysterious and impossible to fully trust, the Prince of Hearts creates constant tension whenever he appears.
3. The fairy-tale world is beautiful and dangerous at the same time. Curses, magical doors, royal palaces, legends and deadly kisses create a setting that feels enchanting without ever being completely safe.
4. The romance develops through uncertainty rather than instant trust. Evangeline and Jacks are connected by bargains, secrets and attraction, but readers are never allowed to forget how dangerous he can be.
5. The story constantly twists familiar fairy-tale expectations. Princes may not be heroes, villains may not be simple, and getting what you wish for may be the beginning of the problem.
6. It is the correct starting point for Evangeline and Jacks’ story. Readers can begin here and continue directly into The Ballad of Never After and A Curse for True Love.
7. It combines romance, fantasy and mystery in an addictive way. Readers who enjoy magical worlds but also want emotional tension, secrets and plot twists receive all three.

Why Read Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber?

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber is an excellent choice for readers interested in YA fantasy romance, fairy-tale retellings and fairy-tale-inspired fantasy, morally grey characters, magical bargains, curses, royal settings, slow-burn romantic tension and whimsical but dangerous worlds.

It is especially suitable for readers who love the idea of a romance where the central question is not simply:

“Will they fall in love?”

but also:

“Should she trust him at all?”

The book understands the appeal of fairy tales.

We want to believe in perfect endings.

We want the kiss to break the curse.

We want the right person to recognize true love.

But Stephanie Garber asks what happens when stories are less predictable.

What if the kiss is dangerous?

What if the bargain changes the heroine?

What if the person who looks like the villain becomes impossible to forget?

That uncertainty is exactly what makes the book addictive.

Who Should Read This Book?

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber may especially appeal to fans of Stephanie Garber, readers who loved Caraval, YA fantasy romance readers, BookTok fantasy fans, readers who enjoy morally grey male characters, fans of cursed romance, readers who like magical royalty, readers who enjoy fairy-tale aesthetics and anyone looking for a fantasy series built around hope, heartbreak and dangerous attraction.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber – Every Happily Ever After Has a Price

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber begins with a girl who believes love should behave like a fairy tale.

Evangeline believes that if love is true enough, there must be a way to save it.

So when her heart breaks, she searches for magic.

And magic answers.

Unfortunately, it answers in the form of Jacks.

The Prince of Hearts offers exactly what fairy tales teach us to desire:

A miracle.

But miracles have prices.

Evangeline agrees before she fully understands what she is giving away.

That mistake sends her into a world of:

Curses.

Princes.

Prophecies.

Betrayals.

Deadly kisses.

And stories that keep changing every time she believes she understands them.

Yet the most interesting part of Evangeline’s journey is not that she continues believing in love.

It is that she gradually has to become wiser about what love actually means.

True love cannot simply be:

Possession.

Obsession.

Destiny declared by someone else.

A magical spell.

A story everyone expects you to follow.

Love has to involve choice.

And choice becomes difficult when magic keeps interfering with the truth.

Jacks makes that problem even harder.

He is exactly the kind of character Evangeline should avoid.

He manipulates.

He bargains.

He hides motives.

He is dangerous.

Yet he also repeatedly becomes the person she cannot completely remove from her story.

That contradiction powers the entire novel.

A fairy tale usually tells readers who the hero is.

Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber asks readers to keep guessing.

For anyone who enjoys magical romance, dangerous princes, curses, fairy-tale mysteries and stories where every beautiful thing may be hiding a darker cost, this is an addictive first step into Evangeline Fox and Jacks’ unforgettable world.

Learn more about Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber on the official Macmillan website.

Explore more fantasy romance books at Bargain Books.